Dry 26%

Wet 37%

Snow 21%

Comfort 5%

Value 11%

Dry 26% · Wet 37% · Snow 21% · Comfort 5% · Value 11%

Dry

Wet

Snow

Comfort

Value

Fine-tune sub-categories

Dry

Dry Braking

Dry Handling

Wet

Wet Braking

Wet Handling

Straight Aqua

Snow

Snow Braking

Snow Handling

Comfort

Noise

Value

Wear

Value

Price

Rolling Resistance

Test Results Data

BEST Good Average Below Average

#	Tyre	Total Score	Dry			Wet				Snow			Comfort		Value
#	Tyre	Total Score	Braking M	Handling Km/H	%	Braking M	Handling Km/H	Straight Aqua Km/H	%	Braking M	Handling Km/H	%	Noise dB	%	Wear KM	Value Price/1000	Price	Rolling Resistance kg / t	%
1	Michelin CrossClimate Plus	93.8%	39.9	85.7 2	97.1%	48.6	71	70	92.4%	25.4	56.7 2	95.7%	73.7	96.7%	70800 ★	6.36	450	9.38	88.9%
2 ▲1	Goodyear Vector 4 Seasons Gen 2	93.3%	44.4	83.3	90.9%	47.5	70.9	72.9	93.6%	23.6 2	56.9 ★	99.4%	72	99%	64100 3	6.4	410	9.35 3	87%
3 ▲1	Continental AllSeasonContact	93%	42.6	84.4	93.4%	49.9	71.2 3	68.9	91.3%	24.2 3	56	97.4%	72.7	98.1%	67700 2	6.35 3	430	8.64 2	90.5%
4 ▼2	Vredestein Quatrac Pro	93%	42.9	85.1 3	93.5%	46.5 3	72.6 ★	70.4	95.2%	24.9	55.9	95.9%	72.1	98.9%	52000	7.21	375	9.86	79.2%
5 ▲1	Nexen N Blue 4 Season	91.9%	42.3	83.4	93.1%	50.4	70	71	90.5%	25.7	56.1	94.6%	71.3 ★	100%	59900	5.34 ★	320 ★	11.02	88%
6 ▼1	Hankook Kinergy 4S2	91.9%	42	84.6	94.1%	50.8	70.6	72.2	90.8%	24.8	56.6	96.7%	72.8	97.9%	50500	6.93	350 3	9.47	81.2%
7 ▲2	Bridgestone Weather Control A005	91.6%	39.7 3	84.4	96.6%	46.3 2	70.8	71.5	94.4%	27.1	54.8	91.1%	73.1	97.5%	39000	10.26	400	8.45 ★	72%
8	Kumho Solus HA31	91.2%	43.8	83.1	91.4%	49.5	69.3	70.5	90.7%	25.6	55.1	93.9%	71.9 3	99.2%	59600	5.96 2	355	10.06	86.3%
9 ▼2	Maxxis Premitra All Season AP3	91.1%	39.5 2	84.2	96.8%	51	68.7	74.3 2	89.8%	26.3	55.7	93.2%	71.8 2	99.3%	48100	7.38	355	9.88	77.7%
10	Cooper Discoverer All Season	89.8%	41.2	82.5	93.8%	52.6	66.2	73.7 3	87%	25.6	55	93.8%	72.4	98.5%	50100	6.69	335 2	9.92	81%
11	Reference Winter	85.7%	44.4	84	91.3%	50.4	70.5	72.1	91%	23.3 ★	56.7 2	99.8%	73.9	96.5%	10.05
12 ▼1	Reference Summer	73.4%	37.9 ★	86.3 ★	100%	42.4 ★	71.6 2	76.8 ★	99.4%	69.3	72.8	33.6%	11.17	97.9%

Scroll for more

Dry 97% Wet 92% Snow 96% Comfort 97% Value 89%

View detailed scores

Dry

Dry Braking 39.9 M

Dry Handling 85.7 Km/H 2

Wet

Wet Braking 48.6 M

Wet Handling 71 Km/H

Straight Aqua 70 Km/H

Snow

Snow Braking 25.4 M

Snow Handling 56.7 Km/H 2

Comfort

Noise 73.7 dB

Value

Wear 70800 KM ★

Value 6.36 Price/1000

Price 450

Rolling Resistance 9.38 kg / t

Dry 91% Wet 94% Snow 99% Comfort 99% Value 87%

View detailed scores

Dry

Dry Braking 44.4 M

Dry Handling 83.3 Km/H

Wet

Wet Braking 47.5 M

Wet Handling 70.9 Km/H

Straight Aqua 72.9 Km/H

Snow

Snow Braking 23.6 M 2

Snow Handling 56.9 Km/H ★

Comfort

Noise 72 dB

Value

Wear 64100 KM 3

Value 6.4 Price/1000

Price 410

Rolling Resistance 9.35 kg / t 3

Dry 93% Wet 91% Snow 97% Comfort 98% Value 91%

View detailed scores

Dry

Dry Braking 42.6 M

Dry Handling 84.4 Km/H

Wet

Wet Braking 49.9 M

Wet Handling 71.2 Km/H 3

Straight Aqua 68.9 Km/H

Snow

Snow Braking 24.2 M 3

Snow Handling 56 Km/H

Comfort

Noise 72.7 dB

Value

Wear 67700 KM 2

Value 6.35 Price/1000 3

Price 430

Rolling Resistance 8.64 kg / t 2

Dry 94% Wet 95% Snow 96% Comfort 99% Value 79%

View detailed scores

Dry

Dry Braking 42.9 M

Dry Handling 85.1 Km/H 3

Wet

Wet Braking 46.5 M 3

Wet Handling 72.6 Km/H ★

Straight Aqua 70.4 Km/H

Snow

Snow Braking 24.9 M

Snow Handling 55.9 Km/H

Comfort

Noise 72.1 dB

Value

Wear 52000 KM

Value 7.21 Price/1000

Price 375

Rolling Resistance 9.86 kg / t

Dry 93% Wet 91% Snow 95% Comfort 100% Value 88%

View detailed scores

Dry

Dry Braking 42.3 M

Dry Handling 83.4 Km/H

Wet

Wet Braking 50.4 M

Wet Handling 70 Km/H

Straight Aqua 71 Km/H

Snow

Snow Braking 25.7 M

Snow Handling 56.1 Km/H

Comfort

Noise 71.3 dB ★

Value

Wear 59900 KM

Value 5.34 Price/1000 ★

Price 320 ★

Rolling Resistance 11.02 kg / t

Dry 94% Wet 91% Snow 97% Comfort 98% Value 81%

View detailed scores

Dry

Dry Braking 42 M

Dry Handling 84.6 Km/H

Wet

Wet Braking 50.8 M

Wet Handling 70.6 Km/H

Straight Aqua 72.2 Km/H

Snow

Snow Braking 24.8 M

Snow Handling 56.6 Km/H

Comfort

Noise 72.8 dB

Value

Wear 50500 KM

Value 6.93 Price/1000

Price 350 3

Rolling Resistance 9.47 kg / t

Dry 97% Wet 94% Snow 91% Comfort 98% Value 72%

View detailed scores

Dry

Dry Braking 39.7 M 3

Dry Handling 84.4 Km/H

Wet

Wet Braking 46.3 M 2

Wet Handling 70.8 Km/H

Straight Aqua 71.5 Km/H

Snow

Snow Braking 27.1 M

Snow Handling 54.8 Km/H

Comfort

Noise 73.1 dB

Value

Wear 39000 KM

Value 10.26 Price/1000

Price 400

Rolling Resistance 8.45 kg / t ★

Dry 91% Wet 91% Snow 94% Comfort 99% Value 86%

View detailed scores

Dry

Dry Braking 43.8 M

Dry Handling 83.1 Km/H

Wet

Wet Braking 49.5 M

Wet Handling 69.3 Km/H

Straight Aqua 70.5 Km/H

Snow

Snow Braking 25.6 M

Snow Handling 55.1 Km/H

Comfort

Noise 71.9 dB 3

Value

Wear 59600 KM

Value 5.96 Price/1000 2

Price 355

Rolling Resistance 10.06 kg / t

Dry 97% Wet 90% Snow 93% Comfort 99% Value 78%

View detailed scores

Dry

Dry Braking 39.5 M 2

Dry Handling 84.2 Km/H

Wet

Wet Braking 51 M

Wet Handling 68.7 Km/H

Straight Aqua 74.3 Km/H 2

Snow

Snow Braking 26.3 M

Snow Handling 55.7 Km/H

Comfort

Noise 71.8 dB 2

Value

Wear 48100 KM

Value 7.38 Price/1000

Price 355

Rolling Resistance 9.88 kg / t

Dry 94% Wet 87% Snow 94% Comfort 99% Value 81%

View detailed scores

Dry

Dry Braking 41.2 M

Dry Handling 82.5 Km/H

Wet

Wet Braking 52.6 M

Wet Handling 66.2 Km/H

Straight Aqua 73.7 Km/H 3

Snow

Snow Braking 25.6 M

Snow Handling 55 Km/H

Comfort

Noise 72.4 dB

Value

Wear 50100 KM

Value 6.69 Price/1000

Price 335 2

Rolling Resistance 9.92 kg / t

Dry 91% Wet 91% Snow 100% Comfort 97% Value 84%

View detailed scores

Dry

Dry Braking 44.4 M

Dry Handling 84 Km/H

Wet

Wet Braking 50.4 M

Wet Handling 70.5 Km/H

Straight Aqua 72.1 Km/H

Snow

Snow Braking 23.3 M ★

Snow Handling 56.7 Km/H 2

Comfort

Noise 73.9 dB

Value

Rolling Resistance 10.05 kg / t

Dry 100% Wet 99% Snow 34% Comfort 98% Value 76%

View detailed scores

Dry

Dry Braking 37.9 M ★

Dry Handling 86.3 Km/H ★

Wet

Wet Braking 42.4 M ★

Wet Handling 71.6 Km/H 2

Straight Aqua 76.8 Km/H ★

Snow

Snow Braking 69.3 M

Comfort

Noise 72.8 dB

Value

Rolling Resistance 11.17 kg / t

Not every driver has the same priorities. Adjust the category weightings above to re-rank the tyres based on what matters most to your driving style.

Scores are colour-coded from red (weakest) through yellow to green (strongest) to help you quickly spot each tyre's strengths and weaknesses.

The original test ranking is shown in the # column. Arrows indicate how each tyre moves when your custom weighting is applied.

Discussion

11 comments

Arin Aug 26, 2020 archived

I had the Michelin crossclimate plus, my first all season. My experience is very disappointing regarding wear. They lasted 3 years and 25.000 km. The noise is high. i think that because the car is not moving very much because of the Covid Pandemic, the tiers changed their form and make a strange noise.

#6033
Marius Anghel Apr 16, 2020 archived

Hi,
I am still looking forward to the promised 2020 test, especially since the vector gen 3 has just been launched.

#5700
1. TyreReviews Marius Anghel Apr 16, 2020 archived
  
  I was meant to have that test finished by now, sadly covid has delayed things so it looks like Autumn now :(
  
  #5701
Adrian Cirstea Jan 2, 2020 archived

Best all season tyre for me is by far Michelin Pilot Sport AS 3 Plus! You can buy them on ebay from USA ;)

#5485
1. TyreReviews Adrian Cirstea Jan 3, 2020 archived
  
  There are great tyres, but very different to the European all season tyres in this test!
  
  #5489
2. SS Adrian Cirstea Jun 14, 2020 archived
  
  You can't go in snow with that tyre.
  
  #5882
3. Bodhi Adrian Cirstea Sep 27, 2020 archived
  
  haha and end up paying double? Not a good deal at all :(
  
  #6166
MausyMaus Dec 12, 2019 archived

To all who are looking at the CrossClimate+ :
I had this tyre in this size on our Audi A3
It is a really good tyre but more summer focussed then Winter.
Negative: very loud (even wenn New)
I would recomend Vredestein Quatrac 5 or (if not in your size) Quatrac Pro.
This tyre is way more balanced and the most important: very very quite!
Best regards,
Morris

#5434
1. disqus_757SXbGBg9 MausyMaus Jun 26, 2020 archived
  
  INTERESTING....thinking about rims change, therefore tires as well......thanks for tip...
  i have 195/65/15 cc+ i think they can be loud sometimes.
  snow - satisfied, but in summer best. h/w rain -ok.
  after 2 years rubber a bit harder in cold...therefore i am juggling with pressures to balance the gelatine effect vs ride stiffnes. :-/ https://media3.giphy.com/me...
  
  #5900
pantel Nov 17, 2019 archived

Since you are about to perform an all season tyre test, I would like to share a thought of mine. How do all season and summer tyres from the same manufacturer, compare with each other; For example, Quatrac 5 vs Sportrack 5 or Cinturato allseason vs P1 etc. Thank you for time.

#5357
David Foster-Key Nov 15, 2019 archived

Interesting test - But for me it highlighted just how biased a test can be by the personal priorities / opinions of whoever is executing them:
I recently was looking for a set of tyres for my mother's Ford Fiesta - She doesn't do big distances (the recently-scrapped set of age-expired premium summers it was wearing still had a good 4-5mm of tread), she just wants to be able to stop quickly in the wet or dry - and she wouldn't swap tyres between warm and cold weather (i.e. she won't do separate summer / winter tyres).
I bought her a set of Conti All-Seasons, but if I'd have seen this test I may well have gone for the Bridgestones: Cheaper, better wet and dry braking, better aquaplaning resistance and better fuel consumption. The only reasons this tyre didn't score better here are poor wear (not an issue in an elderly relative's car) and slightly increased noise (also not a problem, as this demographic does not drive all that fast or far at a time and often has lower awareness of such things!).
I think you should have given it a special shout-out recommendation as a good choice for lower annual mileage cars such as my mother's.

#5350

Menu

2019 Auto Bild All Season Tyre Test

Adjust Result Weighting

Dry

Wet

Snow

Comfort

Value

Test Results Data

Similar Tyre Tests

Discussion